张伟, 李玮, 陶冠宏, 李爱农, 覃志豪, 雷光斌, 陈艺曦. 利用STARFM模型提高复杂地表下复种指数遥感提取精度[J]. 农业工程学报, 2020, 36(21): 175-185. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2020.21.021
    引用本文: 张伟, 李玮, 陶冠宏, 李爱农, 覃志豪, 雷光斌, 陈艺曦. 利用STARFM模型提高复杂地表下复种指数遥感提取精度[J]. 农业工程学报, 2020, 36(21): 175-185. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2020.21.021
    Zhang Wei, Li Wei, Tao Guanhong, Li Ainong, Qin Zhihao, Lei Guangbin, Chen Yixi. Improvement of extraction accuracy for cropping intensity in complex surface regions using STARFM[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2020, 36(21): 175-185. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2020.21.021
    Citation: Zhang Wei, Li Wei, Tao Guanhong, Li Ainong, Qin Zhihao, Lei Guangbin, Chen Yixi. Improvement of extraction accuracy for cropping intensity in complex surface regions using STARFM[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2020, 36(21): 175-185. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2020.21.021

    利用STARFM模型提高复杂地表下复种指数遥感提取精度

    Improvement of extraction accuracy for cropping intensity in complex surface regions using STARFM

    • 摘要: 复种指数是表征耕地利用程度的重要参数。然而,传统方法存在对影像获取条件要求较高,或在地表复杂区域提取精度较低等问题。高时空分辨率数据融合算法(如Spatial and Temporal Adaptive Reflectance Fusion Model, STARFM)能有效地结合不同数据的优势,有望被应用于提高复杂地表区域复种指数的提取精度。该研究以Landsat TM(Thematic Mapper)及MODIS(Moderate-resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer)为数据源,基于STARFM模型,构建了川东丘陵某区域内2010-2011年的Landsat-like 时序NDVI(Normalized Difference Vegetation Index)数据集,进而提取了该区域2010年冬季作物种植区及盐亭县2011年耕地复种指数的空间分布情况。利用目视解译样点(1509个)验证及多尺度(30~4 000 m)验证方法,对不同方法提取的2010年冬季作物种植区进行了对比分析。结果表明:1)在30m空间尺度上,基于Landsat影像分类法的总体验证精度为89.73%,高于基于Landsat-like时序NDVI峰值法的54.94%;2)在250~4 000 m空间尺度上,基于Landsat-like时序NDVI峰值法的总体验证精度比基于MODIS时序NDVI峰值法高3%~7%。利用统计年鉴及调查样点(73个)数据,对基于新方法提取的盐亭县2011年耕地复种指数结果进行了验证,在县域尺度上其与统计数据非常接近;其与调查样点的总体验证精度达到73.97%。综上,基于数据融合算法提高数据源空间分辨率的方式,不仅能够提高复杂地表复种指数结果的空间精细程度和提取精度,而且在实际应用中也有很好的实用性。

       

      Abstract: Cropping intensity (CI) is essentially related to the utilization condition of arable land. A classification method based on high spatial resolution data (TM), and a peak-counting method based on high temporal resolution NDVI data (MODIS NDVI) are mainly used to extract CI in remotely sensed field. However, it is difficult to acquire the high spatial resolution data with high quality characteristics in the most classification method, as three requirements cannot be satisfied concurrently. The first condition is the time requirement, where the high spatial resolution data can be observed in the growing season. The second one is the frequency requirements, where at least one period of data can be obtained in the growing season. The third one is the quality requirement, where the data cannot be polluted by the cloud, mist and other environmental surroundings. Furthermore, the performance was relatively low, when the peak-counting method was applied in some complex surface regions, since the high temporal resolution data has the low spatial resolution (>250 m). A feasible strategy can be made to obtain a high extraction accuracy of CI, in order to improve the spatial resolution of high temporal resolution data in the use of spatiotemporal data fusion (Spatial and Temporal Adaptive Reflectance Fusion Model, STARFM). Taking the hilly region in the eastern Sichuan as a research area, the 2010-2011 time series Landsat-like NDVI dataset with high temporal and spatial resolution was collected to extract the spatial distribution of cropping area for the winter-season in2010 and the CI for summer- and winter-seasons in 2011 in Yanting County, using the STARFM algorithm, Landsat TM and MODIS data. Precision validation between different data in various methods was done at a series of spatial scales (30-4 000 m), referring to the visual interpretation of 1509 random samples, and the spatial distribution of cropping area for winter-season in2010 using Landsat data. The results showed that: 1) Compared to the peak-counting method using Landsat-like time-series NDVI dataset, the overall accuracy of verification was higher for the classification method using Landsat data (89.73% vs. 54.94%), at the scale of 30 m. 2) Compared to the peak-counting method using MODIS time-series NDVI dataset, the overall accuracy of verification was higher 3%-7% for the peak-counting method using Landsat-like time-series NDVI dataset, at the scales from 250 m to 4 000 m. 3) The overall accuracy of verification was higher 0.17, when the data from the new method was spatially aggregated from 30 m to 4 000 m. In the CI result of 2011 in Yanting County, the data in the Mianyang Statistical Yearbook of 2011, and 73 samples from the field survey data in August 2013 were used to validate the practicability of new method. There were very close CI values from the statistical data (1.69) and new method (1.67), indicating that the overall accuracy of verification was 73.97% in the field survey. A high accuracy of extraction and fine spatial details of CI can be acquired, when using the fusion of spatiotemporal data in some complex surface regions. The findings can contribute to the evaluation of food production and carbon sequestration potential in complex surface regions.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回