姚荣江, 杨劲松, 郑复乐, 王相平, 谢文萍, 张新, 尚辉. 基于表观电导率和Hydrus模型同化的土壤盐分估算[J]. 农业工程学报, 2019, 35(13): 91-101. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2019.13.010
    引用本文: 姚荣江, 杨劲松, 郑复乐, 王相平, 谢文萍, 张新, 尚辉. 基于表观电导率和Hydrus模型同化的土壤盐分估算[J]. 农业工程学报, 2019, 35(13): 91-101. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2019.13.010
    Yao Rongjiang, Yang Jinsong, Zheng Fule, Wang Xiangping, Xie Wenping, Zhang Xing, Shang Hui. Estimation of soil salinity by assimilating apparent electrical conductivity data into HYDRUS model[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2019, 35(13): 91-101. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2019.13.010
    Citation: Yao Rongjiang, Yang Jinsong, Zheng Fule, Wang Xiangping, Xie Wenping, Zhang Xing, Shang Hui. Estimation of soil salinity by assimilating apparent electrical conductivity data into HYDRUS model[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2019, 35(13): 91-101. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2019.13.010

    基于表观电导率和Hydrus模型同化的土壤盐分估算

    Estimation of soil salinity by assimilating apparent electrical conductivity data into HYDRUS model

    • 摘要: 精细刻画农田土壤盐分运移过程对盐渍化精准治理具有重要意义。该文以磁感式大地电导率仪EM38测定的土壤表观电导率作为数据源,利用表观电导率与剖面土壤盐分之间的反演模型作为观测算子,将集合卡尔曼滤波(ensemble Kalman filter,EnKF)同化方法应用于土壤水盐运移过程模型(HYDRUS-1D),进行滨海盐渍农田周年土壤盐分动态的模拟,并分析了同化过程的敏感性。结果表明:与单纯使用HYDRUS模型相比,EnKF同化方法对模型观测算子的更新,有效提高剖面土壤盐分模拟精度,且EnKF同化值的精度优于EnKF同化模拟值,在同化过程中的调整量亦最大;敏感性分析结果显示土壤盐分同化过程对状态变量集合数大小不敏感,对观测数据误差和引入观测数据的深度较为敏感,观测数据误差水平越高、引入观测数据的深度越浅其误差越大。研究表明基于水盐运移模型和土壤表观电导率数据的EnKF同化方法能提高土壤盐分的模拟精度,为利用多源数据和机理模型进行较大尺度生态过程模拟预测提供了有效手段。

       

      Abstract: Abstract: Accurate and real-time information on soil salinity is required to understand the evolution of soil salinization, to develop appropriate management strategies, and to implement practices to improve the soil productivity and ecological restoration. Therefore, describing the accurate process of soil salt transport is of great significance for the precise management of salt-affected soils. Using the proximal soil sensor (electromagnetic induction, type EM38) and ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) method, this study investigated the feasibility of soil salinity estimation by assimilating 1-D hydrological model (HYDRUS-1D) and apparent electrical conductivity data measured by EM38. Soil sampling and periodical EM38 survey at 11 dates was performed in the experimental site, located in a marine-terrestrial interlaced area in north Jiangsu Province. Soil physical and chemical properties, groundwater attributes and meteorological data were also collected as driving data of assimilation system during November 2015 and October 2016. The inversion model relating apparent electrical conductivity to soil salinity was adopted as observation operator, and EnKF method was applied to HYDRUS-1D model to simulate soil salinity on the profile. This study also examined the sensitivity of simulation accuracy to ensemble number, error level and number of soil salinity observation data during assimilation procedure. The main conclusions included: 1) EnKF assimilation method improved the simulation accuracy of soil salinity on 0-1 m profile. In comparison with simulated value after EnKF assimilation and HYDRUS-simulated value, the root mean square error of EnKF assimilation value decreased and the NSE of EnKF assimilation value increased. This indicated that EnKF assimilation value was more accurate than the simulated value after EnKF assimilation, whereas the simulated value after EnKF assimilation was better than HYDRUS-simulated value; 2) The simulated value after EnKF assimilation was closer to the measured value than HYDRUS-simulated value, and the soil salinity adjustment of EnKF assimilation value was greater than those of simulated value after EnKF assimilation and HYDRUS-simulated value during the assimilation procedure. In general, the adjustment amount of soil salinity was small when the temporal dynamics of soil salinity was flat for EnKF assimilation, whereas drastic soil salinity dynamics resulted in the increase of adjustment amount, for instance the soil salt leaching in the rainy season, indicating the improvement of simulation accuracy. The difference between simulated value after EnKF assimilation and measured value varied from (0.137 to 0.227 g/kg, with an average of 0.097 g/kg, whereas the difference between HYDRUS-simulated value and measured value ranged between 0.082 and 0.437 g/kg, with an average of 0.289 g/kg. 3) Soil salinity assimilation was not sensitive to ensemble size, whereas the error level and number of observation data were sensitive to soil salinity assimilation. The EnKF simulation result of soil salinity for ensemble size 75 was similar to that for ensemble size 100, and no further improvement was observed when ensemble size increased to 75. Also, no further improvement occurred when the error level of observation data exceeded 10% during the EnKF assimilation. Generally, high error level and low involved number of observation data in the EnKF assimilation resulted in large deviation, and vice versa. The improvement of surface soil observation data to the simulation of deep soil salinity attenuated with the increase of soil depth, and the assimilation of deep soil salinity was more sensitive to the involved number of observation data than that of surface soil salinity. It was concluded that, using the ensemble Kalman filter method, the coupled application of HYDRUS model and apparent electrical conductivity data improved the simulation performance of soil salinity. This study provided an effective way for the prediction of large scale ecological processes using multi-source data and mechanism model. More efforts should be diverted to the integration and assimilation of multi-source data at larger scales, such as the proximally sensed data and remote sensing data, and the optimization of model parameter and observation data acquisition frequency.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回