朱婉雪, 李仕冀, 张旭博, 李洋, 孙志刚. 基于无人机遥感植被指数优选的田块尺度冬小麦估产[J]. 农业工程学报, 2018, 34(11): 78-86. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2018.11.010
    引用本文: 朱婉雪, 李仕冀, 张旭博, 李洋, 孙志刚. 基于无人机遥感植被指数优选的田块尺度冬小麦估产[J]. 农业工程学报, 2018, 34(11): 78-86. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2018.11.010
    Zhu Wanxue, Li Shiji, Zhang Xubo, Li Yang, Sun Zhigang. Estimation of winter wheat yield using optimal vegetation indices from unmanned aerial vehicle remote sensing[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2018, 34(11): 78-86. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2018.11.010
    Citation: Zhu Wanxue, Li Shiji, Zhang Xubo, Li Yang, Sun Zhigang. Estimation of winter wheat yield using optimal vegetation indices from unmanned aerial vehicle remote sensing[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2018, 34(11): 78-86. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2018.11.010

    基于无人机遥感植被指数优选的田块尺度冬小麦估产

    Estimation of winter wheat yield using optimal vegetation indices from unmanned aerial vehicle remote sensing

    • 摘要: 田块尺度作物快捷精准估产对规模化农业经营管理具有重要意义。因此,急需选取最优植被指数和最佳无人机遥感作业时期,建立冬小麦无人机遥感估产模型,获取及时、快速、低成本的无人机遥感估产方法。该文以山东省滨州市典型规模化农田为研究对象,利用固定翼无人机遥感平台对冬小麦进行多期遥感观测与估产。基于2016年冬小麦返青拔节期、抽穗灌浆期和成熟期的无人机遥感影像数据集,采用最小二乘法,构建了基于不同植被指数与冬小麦实测产量的9种线性模型,并结合作物实测产量进行模型评价。多时相多种类植被指数的优选分析结果显示,抽穗灌浆期估产模型R2最高,RMSE最低(n=34)。其中,模型R2达到0.70的植被指数共6个,从高到低依次为EVI2、MSAVI2、SAVI、MTVI1、MSR和OSAVI;RMSE由低到高依次为EVI2、MSAVI2、SAVI、MTVI1、MSR和OSAVI。另外,该文进一步评价农田土壤像元对无人机遥感估产的影响,经过阈值滤波法处理后,返青拔节期估产模型的R2(n=34)从约0.20提升至0.30以上,RMSE和MRE下降;抽穗灌浆期模型的RMSE降低,R2(n=34)有所提升但不显著。综上所述,最佳无人机飞行作业时期为冬小麦抽穗灌浆期,最优植被指数为EVI2,土壤像元的滤除对抽穗灌浆期无人机遥感估产模型的影响不显著。因此,优化后的基于植被指数的无人机遥感估产模型,可以快速有效诊断和评估作物长势和产量,为规模化农业种植经营提供一种快捷高效的低空管理工具。

       

      Abstract: Abstract: Fast and accurate prediction of crop yield at field scale is an effective way to optimize agricultural management by government or local farmers for improving agriculture production. Compared with satellite remote sensing, unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) remote sensing monitoring system has some advantages, such as obtaining images at high spatial resolution rapidly and cost-effectively, and flying under the clouds at low altitude. The complex equations and methods were commonly used to improve accuracy of yield prediction, but lacked quickness and simplicity. Thus, the object of this study was to: 1) Explore the optimal vegetation index (VI) and operation time to enhance the accuracy and quickness of yield prediction by wing-fixed UAV during wheat growing season. 2) Verify and improve the applicability of this method based on satellite remote sensing to UAV remote sensing research. The study was carried out 3 times i.e. from green to jointing stage, from the heading to filling stage, and the maturation stage during winter wheat growing season in 2016 in Binzhou City, which is in northwestern Shandong Province. In order to get stable winter wheat canopy multi-spectral datum, the cloudless and calm weather with better lighting conditions were selected to conduct the monitoring. Whiteboard data were collected before each monitoring event for later radiation correction. UAV remote sensing images with a spatial resolution of 0.16 m were generated after radiation correction, image mosaic and orthographical correction. In addition, 9 common vegetation indices (VIs) were calculated from green, red, red edge and near-infrared images, including EVI2 (enhanced vegetation index without a blue band), MSAVI2 (modified secondary soil adjusted vegetation index), OSAVI (optimized soil adjusted vegetation index), NDVI (normalized difference vegetation index), SAVI (soil adjusted vegetation index), MCARI (modified chlorophyll absorption ratio index), MTVI1 (modified triangular vegetation index), GNDVI (green normalized difference vegetation index) and MSR (modified simple ratio). Models of VIs and measured yield were obtained using the least squares regression method. To assess validity and generalization of the model, we validated models via the leave-one-out cross validation procedure which is applicable to small sample data. The measured yield data and UAV remote sensing data of wheat showed the spatial heterogeneity of different field yields and VIs were significant, so the samples have a good representation. Analysis of the multi-period UAV remote sensing images showed that R2 values of 6 models reached 0.70 following the order of EVI2 > MSAVI2 > SAVI > MTVI1 > MSR > OSAVI. And corresponding RMSE (root mean square error) value of them followed the order of EVI2 < MSAVI2 < SAVI < MTVI1 < MSR < OSAVI. Moreover, due to remote sensing images with very high resolution, soil pixels could be filtered to gain pure vegetation pixels by threshold filtering method. Data in mature stage weren't suitable for prediction because of senescent leaves and lack of chlorophyll, so they were excluded. The soil filtered result showed the R2 (n=34) of yield estimation was increased from about 0.20 to over 0.30 from the green to jointing stage, and corresponding RMSE and mean relative error were decreased. Although the R2 of yield prediction models was not changed obviously from heading to filling stage, RMSE and mean relative error of them decreased remarkably. In summary, the heading-filling period was the optimal period for winter wheat yield prediction with VIs at a single stage, and corresponding optimal VI was EVI2 with R2 (n=34) value of 0.73, and RMSE value of 579.93 kg/hm2. We concluded that the traditional statistical regression method of crop yield and vegetation index is also suitable for UAV remote sensing, and optimal yield prediction model based on EVI2 can diagnose and assess the growth and yield of winter wheat quickly and accurately, which can provide a practical and high-efficiency way at low latitude for large-scale agricultural planting and management.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回