王国英, 袁京, 孔艺霖, 沈玉君, 杨燕, 李国学. 堆肥种子发芽指数测定方法与敏感性种子筛选[J]. 农业工程学报, 2021, 37(19): 220-227. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2021.19.025
    引用本文: 王国英, 袁京, 孔艺霖, 沈玉君, 杨燕, 李国学. 堆肥种子发芽指数测定方法与敏感性种子筛选[J]. 农业工程学报, 2021, 37(19): 220-227. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2021.19.025
    Wang Guoying, Yuan Jing, Kong Yilin, Shen Yujun, Yang Yan, Li Guoxue. Determination of seed germination index and selection of sensitive seeds for phytotoxicity evaluation of composting[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2021, 37(19): 220-227. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2021.19.025
    Citation: Wang Guoying, Yuan Jing, Kong Yilin, Shen Yujun, Yang Yan, Li Guoxue. Determination of seed germination index and selection of sensitive seeds for phytotoxicity evaluation of composting[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering (Transactions of the CSAE), 2021, 37(19): 220-227. DOI: 10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2021.19.025

    堆肥种子发芽指数测定方法与敏感性种子筛选

    Determination of seed germination index and selection of sensitive seeds for phytotoxicity evaluation of composting

    • 摘要: 种子发芽指数(Germination Index,GI)作为评价堆肥腐熟度的权威指标,被广泛应用于评价堆肥产品植物毒性等方面,但对于GI测定方法和供试种子类型仍缺少统一标准,导致不同堆肥研究的GI结果缺乏可比性。为此,该研究通过设置不同毒性梯度的堆肥试验、选取不同类型种子,详细介绍了GI测定方法,规定根长为0和1 mm的计量标准以及根长起始测量位置,并系统分析了表征堆肥腐熟度指标与种子发芽之间响应关系。结果表明:最终产品GI以纯猪粪(26.54%~80.49%)、纯羊粪(16.71%~92.98%)、猪粪+秸秆(28.28%~110.74%)、羊粪+秸秆(43.38%~119.69%)的顺序递增。综合分析不同堆肥处理理化指标(温度、氧气、pH值、碳氮比)和植物毒性因子(电导率、铵根、有机酸和有机质)与不同种子GI(黄瓜、萝卜、白菜、油菜)相关性关系,发现萝卜种子响应度最高(r=0.96),在综合表征堆肥腐熟度和植物毒性上最具科学性和代表性。以上结果可为种子发芽指数测定、有机肥标准制定以及堆肥农田安全施用提供参考。

       

      Abstract: Composting has historically been carried out by farmers for manure management, which is a reliable way to recycle manure for use on croplands in sustainable agriculture. However, poor management of the composting process can result in un-mature compost product, which inhibits plant growth and deteriorates soil condition. The seed Germination Index (GI), an authoritative parameter to evaluate the maturity of compost, has been widely utilized in evaluating the phytotoxicity and other aspects of composting process. However, there are still lack of unified standards for the measurement method of GI and the representative type of experimental seed until now, which leads to the diverse results of GI (fluctuated from 20%-217%), and the newest standard of organic fertilizer (NY525–2021) requirements GI≥70% of organic fertilizer. Thus, it is meaningless to compare these values between different studies in related fields and urgently for public to provide a reference measurement process for GI during composting. Therefore, this study protocoled four treatments, composting chicken manure with or without auxiliary material (carbon additive) for different phytotoxicity compost, and selected four types of seeds for sensitive assays according to previous studies, mainly included cucumber, radish, Chinese cabbage and oil rape. Besides, in the process of germination experiments and indexes calculation, detailly instruction for the whole process of GI determination and calculation was documented, which stipulated the definition of radical length for 0, 1 mm and the start position for measure (with diagram). Furthermore, systematically detecting the response relationships between influenced parameters and GI of different composting treatments. The results showed that, according to the GI of final compost, the maturity increased in the order of pure pig manure treatment (26.54%-80.49%), pure sheep manure treatment (16.71%-92.98%), pig manure and straw treatment (28.28%-110.74%), sheep manure and straw treatment (43.38%-119.69%). Carbon additive of straw could significantly improve temperature of composting systems and further maturity of the final products. Increasing pH and decreasing phytotoxicity of electronical conductivity, low molecular organic acid and organic matter contents at the same time. Seeds’ GI decreased with the order of radish (≤130%), cucumber (≤100%), oil rape (≤70%), Chinese cabbage (≤45%). The sensitives were reflected with correlation analysis, which between physical and chemical indicators (temperature, oxygen, pH, carbon and nitrogen ratio) and biological toxicity factors (electronical conductivity, ammonium nitrogen, organic acid and organic matter) and GI with different seeds (cucumber, radish, cabbage, rape) of four composting processes, and fond the factors influenced GI with the sequence of NH4+, pH value, O2, VS, VFAs, EC, C/N, temperature, which was in accordance with the affected sequence of radish seed. Besides, radish seed showed the highest responsivity (3.69, r=0.96) of GI for influenced factors, which was the most scientific and representative type of seeds for comprehensively reflecting maturity and phytotoxicity of compost of discrepancy qualities compost. Furthermore, radish has been widely studied for the reasons of fasting germination speed, moderating molecular size, obtaining easily and lowering price. These results can provide scientific references for the determination and comparation of GI, the establishment of organic fertilizer standards and the safe application of compost in farmlands.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回