流域农业面源负荷不确定性及其成因量化分析

    Identifying the key influencing factors to assess the uncertainty of pollution loads from agricultural non-point sources in watersheds

    • 摘要: 明确面源污染物驱动机制及其响应规律,定量解析面源负荷的不确定性特征,是流域面源污染治理的关键内容之一。该研究以长江上游岷沱江和嘉陵江流域74个封闭汇流区为研究对象,基于长序列水文、水质监测数据、污染源统计数据和下垫面数据,分析了驱动-农业面源负荷关系。通过特征阈值控制流量-面源负荷点位集的Delaunay网络尾部噪声,识别边界的几何敏感度,捕捉流量-面源负荷数据集的空间分布形态和潜在的不确定性区域,提出了一种基于非参数化Alpha Shapes包络线算法和加权最小二乘回归方法的面源负荷不确定性定量方法。通过对面源负荷上边界包络线倾角、下边界包络线倾角和包络角变化范围的量化,分析了不同水文条件和下垫面条件对面源负荷不确定性的影响。结果表明:4种污染物面源负荷均呈右偏对数正态分布;氨氮(NH3-N)、高锰酸盐指数(CODMn)、总磷(TP)的极大值主要受高强度、低频率且分布高度不均的降雨过程影响;总氮(TN)极大值主要受污染源影响。4种污染面源负荷及其变化范围均随流量的增加而增大,最大负荷的变化幅度显著的超过平均负荷的变化幅度。NH3-N、CODMn和TP的面源负荷的上边界包络线倾角的变异性大于下边界包络线倾角的变异性,上边界包络线倾角和下边界包络线倾角随着降雨量的增长而表现出明显的增加的趋势,然而包络角随降雨增加而减小。NH3-N和TP面源负荷对径流量变化的响应更为敏感,下垫面信息量增加将导致4种污染面源负荷不确定性显著增加。4种污染物面源负荷不确定性表现出显著的年际差异,NH3-N与河网密度、自然植被覆盖及汇流区面积等因子均无显著相关性,CODMn、TN和TP面源负荷的不确定性随自然植被覆盖度增加而增加。该非参数Alpha Shapes算法基于多源数据集定量化了流量-面源污染负荷范围的关系,确定了水文条件和流域下垫面因子对面源负荷不确定的影响机制,为识别流域不确定性负荷来源及流域精准化管理提供了科学依据。

       

      Abstract: Non-point source (NPS) pollution has posed a serious risk in the watershed. It is often required for the driving mechanisms and response patterns of the NPS pollutants. In this study, the quantitative analysis was conducted on their load uncertainty associated with the NPS pollution. 74 representative catchments were located in the Mintuo and Jialing River basins, the tributaries of the upper Yangtze River. The dataset was collected from the long-term monitored hydrologic and water quality data, geospatial data of the underlying surfaces, and pollution source inventories. An uncertainty quantitative framework was presented to integrate α-shape envelope algorithms with the weighted least squares regression. The tail noise was controlled in the Delaunay triangulation network of the NPS dataset, according to the characteristic threshold. The boundary geometric sensitivity was simultaneously regulated to capture the spatial patterns and potential uncertainty regions within the dataset. NPS load variability was systematically characterized using three key parameters, i.e., the slope of the upper boundary envelope (the maximum potential loads), the slope of the lower boundary envelope (the baseline transport capacity), and the envelope angle (the range of load fluctuations). The variation range of the NPS loads was also quantified to explore the impacts of the different hydrological and underlying surface conditions on the uncertainty of NPS loads. The results revealed that there were consistent right-skewed log-normal distributions across all pollutants, hydrological-driven extremes for the ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N), permanganate index (CODMn), and total phosphorus (TP) tied to <5% of storm events, and source-dominated total nitrogen (TN) maxima unaffected by rainfall intensity. A statistically significant positive correlation was observed between runoff volume and both the magnitude and variability of NPS (NPS) pollutant loads of NH3-N, CODMn, TP, and TN, indicating the increasing load quantities and variation ranges under elevated runoff conditions. The variability of the upper boundary envelope angles for NH3-N, CODMn, and TP NPS loads exceeded that of the lower boundary envelope angles. The range of the maximum loads for the four pollutants significantly surpassed the degree of variation in the average loads. NH3-N and TP NPS loads exhibited higher sensitivity to changes in runoff. The uncertainty of NPS loads for the four pollutants demonstrated the significant interannual variability. The angles of both the lower and upper boundary envelopes for the four pollutants shared a clear increasing trend as the rainfall increased. Whereas the envelope angles decreased with the increasing rainfall. The increasing information content of the underlying surface led to a substantial rise in the uncertainty of the NPS loads. NH3-N exhibited no significant correlation with the influencing factors, such as the river network density, vegetation coverage, and watershed area, while the uncertainty of the CODMn, TN, and TP NPS loads decreased with the increasing natural vegetation coverage. The uncertainty in the CODMn and TN loads was predominantly influenced by the underlying surface conditions, whereas the TP uncertainty exhibited the dual dependence on both runoff processes and surface conditions. The non-parametric Alpha Shapes algorithm was applied to quantify the flow-dependent variation in the NPS pollution load using multi-source datasets. There was some influence of the hydrological and underlying surface factors on the load uncertainty. The finding can also provide a scientific basis to identify the key sources of uncertainty in the basin and watershed.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回